The age of artificially intelligent humanoid robots is upon us. I’ve been
waiting to interact with one ever since I watched Michael Crichton’s 1973 film
Westworld. However, the AIs in this movie needed some of their kinks worked out;
they ended up going haywire where one repeatedly tried to kill the main
characters. The fear of artificial intelligence surrounding this movie is
evident.
But the anxiety isn’t unwarranted. Tay was a whimsical AI chatbot released by
Microsoft on Twitter years ago, initially trained to demonstrate a personality
and generate some small talk. Microsoft had regular people chat with the bot
while the bot learned from the users. Tay morphed into a sex-crazed neo-Nazi.
The danger here is obvious. Despite the impressive advancements in the
capabilities of information gathering and responsivity, a critical fear of this
technology is not only the level of intelligence that these robots may reach,
but the potentially sinister ambitions paired with their growing intelligence.
Tay is a classic example, but one does not have to look farther than the
Spongebob Squarepants episode “Krab Borg” where the paranoia of world domination
by power hungry robots cripples the main character to the point where he is no
longer able to distinguish real fish from robot fish.
Though this cartoon seems absurd, it’s not too far from where AI robots are
heading. A key factor in this paranoia is the sheer artistry behind the physical
appearance of these AIs, some of which, notably those of Hanson Robotics, have
incredibly detailed facial features. We’ve seen David Hanson’s Sophia, a robot
programmed with emotions and capable of recognizing and simulating faces and
various hand gestures. Her appearance and mannerisms closely resemble those of
real women, from the presence of pores to the slight creasing around the eyes.
She is an astounding creature procured entirely by man, prompting me to disagree
with Walter Benjamin’s idea that the aura of art “withers in the age of
mechanical reproduction.” The aura I see extending from human-like AIs such as
Sophia is hopeful of a future of truly sentient robots, ones that could develop
true friendships with us and become proper members of human society. It’s the
complexity of emotional programming combined with their facial language that
makes these AIs beautiful. Each interaction with them is a reminder of the
brilliant science behind their eyes.
Citations:
AreaEightyNine, director. Spongebob Squarepants - Night Of The Robot. YouTube, YouTube, 28 Nov. 2018, www.youtube.com/watch?v=ER0WeiMyL7Q.
Benjamin, Walter. The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction, 1936.
Crichton, Michael, director. Westworld. RAD Pictures, 1973.
Hanson, David, director. Robots That "Show Emotion". TED, Feb. 2009,
www.ted.com/talks/david_hanson_robots_that_show_emotion#t-275748.
Metz, Rachel. “Microsoft’s Neo-Nazi Sexbot Was a Great Lesson for Makers of AI Assistants.”
MIT Technology Review, 27 Mar. 2018.
“Poster of the Week- Westworld (1973).” Meathookcinema.com, 8 Aug. 2020, meathookcinema.com/2020/08/08/poster-of-the-week-westworld-1973/.
“Sophia.” Hanson Robotics, 1 Sept. 2020,
www.hansonrobotics.com/sophia/.
Tibbitt, Paul, et al. “Krab Borg.” SpongeBob
SquarePants, Nickelodeon, 29 Mar. 2002.
Hey Rafi what's shakin? I really enjoyed your blog! I do have a question for you aboout your critique of Benjamin. You brought up his quote that "the aura of art 'withers in the age of mechanical reproduction.'" But you declined to explain why he thinks this (the reproducibility of the art). Sophia may have aura now while she is one of a kind, but if there were 100,000 Sophias would each still have the aura of art? The other article we read may provide an answer.
ReplyDeleteI like how you mentioned the critique of AI advancement as well as your belief that this fear may be overblown. I am ocillating between these two points of view myself: On the one hand if tech continues to advance at the exponential level it has been for the past 300 years indefinitely I would be VERY concerned, however, like all J curves, there must be an eventual plateau because the environment/market can no longer handle further expansion at which point tech advancement will stall. Where/when do you think this plateau will occur?